The Benefits of Joining a Writing Critique Group

Former literary agent, now a freelance editor, writing teacher, and IP/story developer for major publishers and creators.

By Mary Kole

A writing critique group could help you get out of a creative slump, or put rocket boosters on your development as a writer. Sure, you may have the support of family and friends, but when it comes to getting real constructive writing feedback on your writing, who do you turn to? Not everyone in your life can be trusted or tasked with this very important role. The answer is simple—a writing critique group. A writing critique group provides writers with valuable feedback from other writers in an organized and structured manner. Here, we’ll discuss the various benefits of joining a writing critique group.

writing critique group

Constructive Criticism in a Writing Critique Group

One of the main benefits of joining a writing critique group is that you will get honest and constructive feedback (more here for constructive feedback examples) on your work from experienced professionals and other writers who are on the same path as you. Getting unbiased writing notes can be invaluable for improving your writing skills, as live reaction from writers and readers gives you insight into what works and what doesn't work in your novel, memoir, story, or essay. Furthermore, it lets you know how readers are likely to interact with your piece, so that you can make adjustments accordingly. Is your novel getting your intentions across? A writing critique group can tell you!

Find Friends and Supporters in a Writing Critique Group

Writers often struggle with loneliness and isolation because they can spend long hours alone, working on their craft in an echo chamber. It’s very tough to retain perspective this way, when it’s just you inside your own mind. Joining a writing critique group helps writers combat this feeling by connecting you with other like-minded individuals who share similar interests and goals as you do. Not only will this provide writing motivation to keep pushing forward, but it also allows for new friendships to form among the members of the group which can last beyond the confines of the meeting itself. The best part of joining a community of writers is that you know that the people in this special circle share your interests and goals.

Professional Opportunities in a Writing Critique Group

A writing critique group might not only provide helpful critiques, they can also open up professional opportunities for its members, such as a book deal, literary representation, or editorial work (though I wouldn’t show up to a writing critique group meeting specifically hoping for or expecting doors to open). You never know when one of your critique group members will get an agent or publishing contract, though. Seeing others succeed will not only provide positive motivation, but it might also give you an association with someone on the inside publishing track.

A Fun and Supportive Atmosphere

Last but not least, one of the most important benefits of joining a writing critique group is that it provides an enjoyable atmosphere where writers can come together to learn from one another in a supportive environment free from judgment (more here on how to give constructive criticism). If you find that this is not the case with your specific group, it’s okay to keep looking. Sometimes it takes more than one try to find the right fit. Ideally, the perfect writing critique group type of atmosphere allows writers to express themselves in ways they otherwise wouldn’t be able to. Meanwhile, they will still receive helpful advice and tips from their peers without worrying about feeling belittled because everyone understands what it takes to write a good story, novel, personal essay, screenplay, or whatever it is that you’re working on.

A writing critique group provides an invaluable service for aspiring authors looking for honest feedback on their work, as well as support from fellow writers in an organized setting. If you're looking for guidance on your next project then consider finding (or starting!) a writing critique group today.

Want writing guidance, feedback, and accountability?

Self-guided writing study is great, but can only take you so far. Apply to Story Mastermind—a small group workshop intensive for your novel, memoir, outline, or picture book idea. Achieve a robust outline or draft, or a portfolio of picture books, in a rigorous but supportive environment. Imagine how much closer you can be to your writing goals after participating in Story Mastermind.