Are Creative Writing Clubs Worth It?

Creative writing clubs can offer support, accountability, and writing notes from people who know the lay of the land. However, there are downsides to creative writing clubs as well. They can sometimes lack structure and guidance, which can be difficult for novice writers. You want to make sure that any creative writing clubs you join have industry professionals at the help, or you may end up wasting your time. Additionally, the opinions of other members may not always be constructive (more here on how to give constructive criticism), and the overall productivity of the group may suffer. You want to make sure that any creative writing clubs you join are full of people who are at the same level as you (or at a slightly more accomplished baseline) and are full of writers who have the same publishing goals. Otherwise, you might not be challenging yourself to the extent you could be.

An Alternative to Creative Writing Clubs

For those looking to take their writing to the next level, a writing workshop intensive like Story Mastermind may be the better choice. Writing workshops and intensives are led by experienced professionals who have the knowledge and expertise to guide novice writers through the creative process. These workshops provide a supportive environment that encourages creativity, while also providing structure and guidance.

The benefit of a writing workshop intensive over creative writing clubs is that they provide a more focused approach to writing, and attract a more serious cohort of writers. Rather than discussing ideas in a group setting, or giving vague judgments on submitted work, the focus of a program like Story Mastermind is on actually creating content that has a rigorous writing craft component. This allows participants to create more polished work, add tools to their writing toolbox, and develop their writing style in a supportive small group setting.

In addition to providing guidance and structure, writing workshops can also provide valuable feedback. Experienced professionals—often missing from creative writing clubs—can provide helpful insight into the strengths and weaknesses of a piece, helping writers to make their work the best it can be. This feedback can be invaluable in helping writers improve their work and perfect their storytelling craft.

Creative writing clubs can be an enjoyable and rewarding experience, but for those looking to truly improve their skills, a writing workshop intensive is the better choice. The structured environment and professional guidance provided by these workshops can help writers hone their craft and create higher-quality works of art.